Retargeting vs. Remarketing and Where Direct Mail Fits In

Retargeting and remarketing both win back people who already showed interest in your business. Retargeting follows anonymous website visitors with ads. Remarketing reaches people you already know, usually by email. Direct mail adds a third lane, a physical piece that lands in the household of someone on your list, and it strengthens both of the others.

Retargeting vs. Remarketing: The Practical Difference

Marketers use the two terms interchangeably, and ad platforms use them loosely. The working difference is still worth knowing, because it decides which tool fits your goal.

Retargeting Remarketing
Who it reaches Website visitors you cannot name Contacts and customers you already know
Data it relies on Cookies and tracking pixels Email lists, customer lists and mailing lists
Typical channels Google display ads, Facebook and Instagram ads Email and direct mail
Best for Pulling back visitors who left without acting Re-engaging leads, past buyers and lapsed customers

Website Retargeting Reaches Visitors You Cannot Name

Website retargeting places a tracking pixel on your site. When a visitor leaves without acting, your ads follow them to other sites and social feeds. It requires no contact information, and it responds to real behavior, such as a product page view.

The tradeoffs are real. Many people tune out display ads, and some use ad blockers. You also never learn who the visitor was, so your sales team has no one to call.

Remarketing Works Best When You Know Who to Reach

Remarketing starts with data you already own: past customers, open leads and subscribers. Because you know who they are, your message can speak to what they bought or asked about.

The limit is reach. Remarketing cannot touch the prospect who browsed your site and left without ever sharing an email address, and your emails compete with a crowded inbox.

Direct Mail Gives Both Strategies a Physical Touchpoint

Direct mail fills the gaps in each approach. When your mailing list is matched to Facebook, Instagram and Google, the household that received your piece sees your message again online. That is how a Presort Plus multichannel program turns one mail piece into a series of impressions.

It also fixes the anonymity problem. When a mail recipient visits your website, LeadMatch identifies them with a name, an address and a record of what they did, so your follow-up goes to a real household. A mail piece sits on the counter, while a display ad scrolls past in seconds. Presort Plus puts these tools to work in one campaign.

Matching Each Approach to the Buyer Journey

Visitors reach your site at different stages, and each approach fits a different one.

Stage What the buyer is thinking What works best
Awareness Knows there is a need, unsure where to start Retargeting ads that keep your brand in view
Consideration Knows the solution, needs more information or better timing Remarketing and direct mail with a clear offer
Decision Ready to buy and comparing providers Personalized direct mail and a fast, trackable way to respond

Personalization matters most at the decision stage. Our guide to personalized direct mail shows how to speak to what each prospect already looked at.

Which Should You Choose: Retargeting, Remarketing or Both?

Most campaigns do best with a combination, and three questions help you decide.

  • Is most of your audience anonymous traffic? Start with website retargeting.
  • Do you have a large list of customers and leads? Start with remarketing.
  • Do you need to know exactly who responded? Add direct mail and tracking to either one.

For a deeper look at fitting mail into a retargeting plan, read our guide to direct mail retargeting strategies. The strongest results come from running all three channels from one job, with one team and one set of results.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is retargeting the same as remarketing?

The terms overlap, and many platforms use them interchangeably. In practice, retargeting usually means ads aimed at website visitors, and remarketing usually means outreach to contacts you already have, such as email or mail.

Can direct mail be used for retargeting?

Yes. Matching your mailing list to social and Google ads lets the same household see your message after your piece arrives. Visitor identification then connects website visits from the mailing to named recipients.

Which is better, retargeting or remarketing?

Neither wins on its own. Retargeting reaches people you cannot name, and remarketing reaches people you can. Combining them with direct mail covers both groups.

Put Retargeting, Remarketing and Direct Mail to Work on Your Next Campaign

You do not have to choose one channel or manage three vendors. Presort Inc. prints and mails your piece, then matches your list to Facebook, Instagram and Google so every recipient sees your offer again. Every scan, call and website visit rolls up to one live dashboard, so you know what worked.

Tell us your goal, audience and quantity, and we will recommend the right setup and put together a quote, usually the same day. Presort Plus is available on direct mail jobs of 5,000 pieces or more, with no minimum contract and no additional paper or postage.

See Presort Plus Multichannel Marketing Services or call 800-754-7678 to talk through your project with a Presort representative.

More Like This